2025-02-05 18:01

banner unionsafete



Save Liverpool Women's Hospital Campaign Group Continues Its 10 Year Fight Against Closure
Of England's Only Dedicated Maternity Hospital

All but 2 Merseyside MPs support closure and the transformation of NHS to the American Healthcare Model

NHS Trade Unions support closure of England's ONLY dedicated Maternity and Gynaecology Hospital

NHS Nurses and Doctors unaware of the facts in the closure plans - lied to by management and the ICB

On a cold and rainy Friday evening in Liverpool, over 100 people gathered not far from the Liverpool Women's Hospital at the local community centre to listen to speakers Leslie Mahmood, and Felicity Dowling joint founders of the SLWH Campaign Group; and Kim Johnson MP, one of only two Merseyside Labour MPs fighting to save the NHS and the Liverpool Women's Hospital from closure.

In doing so, the reforms that Wes Streeting and Keir Starmer are forcing upon the NHS, turning it into the American healthcare model; were highlighted along with the private healthcare companies such as Spire Healthcare who are said to be targeting the site and buildings of the Liverpool Women's Hospital in order to provide further private healthcare services and increase their portfolio of NHS work they already have been contracted to provide.

The event was a truly lively event with members of the public being fully involved via a question and answer session following the two main speakers.

Kim Johnson MP for the constituency in which the Liverpool Women's Hospital is situated, opened the event and introduced the two speakers after welcoming everyone, pointing out that Friday nights are not the public's favourite day for such an event, and most certainly not on a damp and dark evening in January!

But fist some of the basic facts around the hidden agenda of this and previous Governments - the transformation of the NHS into an American healthcare model, and the opening up of the NHS as part of a trade deal with the USA. The closure of hospitals and maternity units across England is central to the transformation plans in order to ensure the 'denial of care' model upon which the US healthcare system is based.

The closure of England's ONLY dedicated and stand alone Maternity Hospital - the Liverpool Women's Hospital - forms the basis of the Cheshire and Merseyside Integrated Care Board's commitment to the Government's 'NHS reform programme', which in effect is simply the transformation of the NHS in England into the American Healthcare model.

This of course fits in with its aim of securing a US trade deal by acquiescing to Trumps demand that our NHS is opened up to US healthcare companies and Pharmaceuticals sector, without which Trump will not agree a trade deal with the UK.

The Cheshire and Merseyside Integrated Care Board's dishonest plan entitled The Case For Change, centres on the closure of the existing Women's Hospital and the transfer of ALL maternity and gynaecological services to an, as yet, unnamed destination!

The Save Liverpool Women's Campaign Group's official response to this was discussed at tonight's meeting, of which this is an excerpt of their evidenced document entitled: 'Response To Gynaecology And Maternity Hospital Services in Liverpool: The Case For Change':

'Discussions to close LWH at its present site on Crown Street and re-locate to a smaller new building adjacent to one of the general hospitals
in Liverpool began in 2015.

The emergence of austerity as the driving political ideology and with cutbacks in funding for the NHS meant that the Liverpool Clinical Commissioning Group (LCCG) had to close one of its hospitals. The Women’s Hospital, although less than 20 years old at the time and being massively underfunded, became a candidate.

The then Chair of the LCCG announced, on a BBC Panorama programme, that Liverpool had too many hospitals and one had to close. The following day it was published in the Liverpool Echo that the chosen hospital was the Women’s Hospital (15 March 2015).

At that time the Five Year Forward View (later re-launched as the Long Term Plan) was published and the Naylor Review
was commissioned.

Briefly, the Five Year Forward View was to make efficiency savings (cuts) by moving some hospital services to community care, which was deemed cheaper. Bed closures ensued and secondary care capacity reduced. However, resources were not invested into the community and social care services; this resulted in waiting lists for elective surgery increasing and longer stays in hospital for patients waiting for social care placements.

Following the Health and Social Care Act (2012), the number of contracts awarded to private providers increased and lucrative contracts were awarded to private hospitals to carry out NHS-funded procedures in an attempt to bring down the waiting list (The King’s Fund 2021).

This was a situation beneficial to private hospitals. They cherry-picked the most low risk uncomplicated procedures, leaving the more complex cases to the NHS. If complications occurred the NHS provided a safety net, as any patient needing critical care was transferred to an NHS facility. Compensation claims were also left for the NHS to pick up as they had outsourced the care to a private provider (Centre for
Health and Public Interest 2014), The COVID pandemic exacerbated the waiting lists, this has led to an increase in the private health care insurance industry and an increase in patients paying for their own health care (British Medical Association 2024). But that was always the plan.

The Naylor Review, [reported by this website at the time: The Naylor Report - Asset Stripping of NHS

Property and Land
] was published in 2017, outlined how profits could be made from selling off NHS land and buildings.

Its findings were in line with the requirements set out in the Sustainability and Transformation Plans (STPs) which were introduced in December 2015, to fast forward NHS England’s Five Year Forward View. Eventually, STPs evolved into what we have today, an Integrated Care System managed by an Integrated Care Board (ICB). This is a statutory body responsible for planning and funding NHS services over a large area.

In this instance, the area is Cheshire and Merseyside, one of 42 such areas.

The Naylor Review, however, could only sell NHS land or close NHS buildings if there was a clinical reason for deeming them unsafe and “not
fit for purpose”. And so began the construction of a clinical case for change at the Women’s and to re-locate it from its valuable Crown Street
site.

The LCCG put forward several clinical arguments to strengthen their evidence for re-locating LWH:

* Lack of adult critical care on–site
* Patient transfers between hospitals
* Inability to support women with complex health needs
* Inadequate space for current neonatal facility
* Unavailability of haematology/pathology services.

They then published a Pre-Consultation Business Case (PCBC, 2017) that set out several options for the re-location of LWH. Their preferred
option was to build a new hospital at the site of the new Royal Hospital, and, connected to the new Royal by a link bridge. The plans were
presented to the North West Clinical Senate for review. They declared it a suboptimal solution and only viable as a short-term solution because
it was not co-located with children’s services. However, the Carillion debacle, and subsequent delay in completing the new Royal Hospital, the
COVID pandemic, underfunding and reorganising of the NHS, and public opposition, forced these plans to be shelved until recently.'

This is the background to, what is effectively the re-launch of the 10 year long campaign to Save Liverpool Women's Hospital (SLWH), supported by the only two Labour Government MPs on Merseyside, Ian Byrne MP Liverpool West Derby, and the host of tonight's meeting, Kim Johnson MP Riverside:

 

Following on from her introduction, Felicity Dowling, one of the founding members of the SLWH campaign group, gave a detailed picture of the reason for the campaign, highlighting the fact that Women's Health and specifically Maternity and Gynaecological services in England are under funded, under resourced, and under attack!

Her presentation to the meeting, provided full details of the blatantly political and dismissive case that the ICB is promoting, complete with false statements and assumptions; as it spends NHS funds meant for patient care, on consultants, reports and a public campaign of smoke and mirrors.

 

Lesley Mahmood, a long standing campaigner and, again a founding member of the SLWH Campaign Group, spoke of the campaign and the need for the public to promote the issues of the campaign, educate both the public and NHS clinical and clerical staff as to the true facts of the closure plans of the ICB for the Liverpool Women's Hospital; and to respond to the distortions and lies issued to NHS staff and their Unions, the leaders of whom seem to be ignorant of the realities; and the huge damage to women's Health and maternity healthcare which will occur as a result of these plans by the Cheshire and Merseyside ICB.

The bottom line is that more babies being each year will die, and more mothers will die or be maimed mentally and physically during childbirth; in Merseyside, Wales, and the Isle of Man - all areas that the Liverpool Maternity Hospital currently takes provides maternity and gynaecological services to!

Introduced by Kim Johnson MP, chair of the meeting, Lesley presented the truth of the lack of understanding of NHS staff and their Trade Unions:

There then followed, a very lively, interesting, and formative question and answers session, with many of the public expressing their commitment to the campaign and a thorough knowledge of the issues and of the duplicity of Merseyside's MPs who simply fail to even try to understand or question the situation and the dire and immediate danger that the planned closure of the Liverpool 8 dedicated and specially built site of England's only dedicated stand-alone maternity hospital and the relocation of Maternity Service on Merseyside to as yet unknown destination; although Manchester has been suggested!!

 

The Key Issues:

1. Maternity is still grossly underfunded and understaffed, nationally and locally. This is reported by the Royal College of Midwives. Misogyny runs deep in NHS decision making, nationally and locally.

2. The NHS is being shifted to the US model of health care. Privatisation under an NHS logo leeches money from front line care and staff working conditions.

3. The entirely preventable winter crisis. Huge thanks and praise to all those working in this crisis. Grievous harm is happening to staff, patients and families. The RCN recently reported that women had miscarried in hospital corridors, and others have died in these conditions. Waiting lists are huge especially in Gynaecology and women’s health.

The Naylor Review:

Readers of this website will already know that, the Government has last month, handed over to the private sector, 'elective care' that the NHS traditionally provides. It is also of course part of the 'long term plan' for the NHS which was started by Blair's Government with Alan Milburn MP the then secretary of state for health and Simon Stevens who was the European CEO of United Health; one of the largest US healthcare corporations. Straight from the Tory playbook written by John Redwood and Oliver Letwin in the Thatcher years, on the best way of setting up the NHS ready for the US modelling of turning it into a healthcare insurance service!

This is in line with Trump's aim to have the NHS 'opened up' to US private healthcare and pharmaceutical companies, and fits perfectly with Starmer's needs for a US/UK trade deal, i place of being part of the EU single market and customs union.

So just what can you do?

Join the campaign to save Liverpool Women's Hospital and sign the on-line petition if you have not already done so. It doesn't matter where you live on Merseyside, we have volunteers and supporters across the whole of Merseyside, Cheshire, and even Lancashire.

The principle issue here is that the closure of maternity hospitals across England continues, let alone the targeting of stand-alone dedicated Maternity Hospitals of which Liverpool's is the only existing one!

It is also very important to:

* Write to your local MP, or ask to see your MP in order to respond to the distorted and factually incorrect statements from the IC in their cased to close the hospital.

* Raise the issue of the NHS generally, and debunk the Case For Change argument that the ICB is telling staff and their Unions.

* Raise too the lies and false promises coming from managers, and the spreading of falsehoods.

E.G. there will NOT be a new building for Maternity built alongside the new Royal Hospital - where is the money to replace a fit for purpose building already existing?

* Put up a poster calling for action n the NHS.

* Give out campaign leaflets in your street.

* Talk to family, friends, work colleagues, fellow students, and neighbours about the need to rescue the NHS from being transformed into the American Healthcare system.

Remember, Healthcare is a human right that the generation that defeated fascism gifted to us the best Healthcare system in the World. This, at a time when the UK was financially worse off than it ever had been since the first World War, and despite opposition from the Tories and even GP bodies.

The NHS has been bled dry by privatisation, by the market in healthcare, by austerity and cuts to funding, by appalling workforce planning, by letting our midwifery service decline, by the frightening damage to our mental health services, by cuts to beds and inadequate staffing and by neglect of the fabric of our NHS buildings. These have all caused grave harm. But each problem can be reversed by government policy, if they so
choose. These atrocities were policy for the Conservatives, and sadly, it appears to be Labour Government policy too.

Source: Save Liverpool Women's Hospital Campaign / Cheshire and Merseyside Coordenated Healthcare Campaign / Cheshire and Merseyside Integrated Care Board / Unionsafety

See Also:

The Smoke And Mirrors Of Labour's Dishonest NHS Policy

NHS Privatisation News Archive

WHO report for further info into poorest households and women's health


Pic: Bak to News icon link

Designed, Hosted and Maintained by Union Safety Services